Even in this crazy era of technology, some crafters prefer mechanical over computerized sewing units.
And I completely understand their decision. Most of the users of mechanical units are newbies without experience. And since mechanical machines are a lot easier to operate than digital ones, it is completely understandable why would they pick something straightforward instead of computerized and complex.
However, those new to the craft are not the only ones who like mechanical machines better than digital ones. I like them as well and I know some of you do too. That is why I reviewed the best units out there.
After you finish reviewing the units, scroll down to learn more about mechanical sewing machine uses & mechanical sewing machine meaning. And do not forget to use the tips on how to choose the best one.
Best Mechanical Sewing Machine Reviews 2020: Updated Chart
Choosing the best mechanical sewing machine requires attention to features, performance, warranty, and construction. Let’s compare some of the greatest units out there and choose a decent one for you.
|Janome HD3000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine – Editor’s Choice||10 x 19 x 15||23 pounds||A built-in needle threader, free arm & auto bobbin winding||25-year limited warranty||$$$$|
|SINGER Heavy Duty 4423 Sewing Machine - Best All Metal Sewing Machine||15.5 x 6.2 x 12||14.5 pounds||Heavy-duty metal frame, a lot of add-ons and 23 built-in stitches||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Janome 2212 Sewing Machine – Mechanical Sewing Machine with Speed Control||17 x 9 x 13.5||16 pounds||Drop feed for free-motion work, and a lot of adjustable features||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Brother XL-3750 Free-Arm Sewing Machine – Mechanical Sewing Machine for Quilting||15.4 x 6.7 x 11.5||17.85 pounds||Lightweight, flatbread convertible machine with quilting features||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Janome HD1000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine – Best Mechanical Sewing Machine 2018||18.2 x 8.5 x 15.2||21.8 pounds||A built-in automatic needle threader, free arm, and many add-ons||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Janome 2206 Sewing Machine – Mechanical Sewing Machine with Automatic Thread Cutter||17 x 9 x 14||14.7 pounds||Front-loading bobbin, free arm, built-in thread cutter, and 860 SPM||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Brother XR3774 Full-Featured Quilting Machine – Best High-End Mechanical Sewing Machine||17.5 x 7.6 x 14.6||19.5 pounds||Versatile, 37 built-in stitches, 8 sewing feet, and a built-in threader||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Janome Magnolia 7318 Sewing Machine||18.8 x 10.5 x 14.8||17.65 pounds||Jam proof, top-loading bobbin system, a handle, and 7-piece feed dogs||5-year warranty||$$|
|SINGER Heavy Duty 4432 Sewing Machine – Best All Metal Sewing Machine||15.2 x 6.2 x 12||17.15 pounds||Reverse stitch sewing machine, heavy-duty metal frame & add-ons||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Brother XM2701 Sewing Machine – Mechanical Machine for Beginners||12.1 x 5.9 x 15.3||12.6 pounds||27 built-in stitches, 6 fast-changing sewing feet, and jam-resistant||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|SINGER Simple 3232 Sewing Machine – Budget’s Pick||15 x 7.5 x 12||12.25 pounds||Fully-automatic 1-step buttonhole, free arm, and free accessories||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|SINGER Heavy Duty 4411 Sewing Machine||15.5 x 6.2 x 12||14.5 pounds||Singer sewing assistant app, a built-in reverse, and top drop-in bobbin||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Brother ST371HD Strong and Tough Sewing Machine – Modern Mechanical Sewing Machine||7.9 x 16.1 x 12.2||18.4 pounds||Easy stitch selection, metal needle plate, and heavyweight needles||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|SINGER Tradition 2277 Sewing Machine||15 x 6.2 x 12||13.6 pounds||Auto needle threader, easy stitch selection, and automatic tension||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|SINGER Start 1304 Sewing machine – Best Mechanical Sewing Machine for Home Use||13 x 7 x 11.5||9.8 pounds||Fast & easy threading, easy stitch selector and 3 presser feet included||25-year limited warranty||$$|
|Brother XM1010 Sewing Machine||5.8 x 15.4 x 12.1||10.8 pounds||Easy stitch selector, free arm, jam-resistant bobbin and add-ons||25-year limited warranty|
16 Best Mechanical Sewing Machine Reviews 2020 - You Need To Read
Let’s check every unit from my chart in detail and take note of their pros and cons before you buy. The best mechanical sewing machine 2020 is out there somewhere. You just have to pay enough attention.
Janome HD3000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine
Тhe Janome machine you will love, especially if you are into heavy-duty projects is the HD3000 sewing machine. Yes, it costs a lot but you will get an exceptional workhorse that will last for years. Meaning, it is a great bargain for the price. And it remains as one of the greatest mechanical sewing units out there.
You will get this model with a jam-proof top-loading bobbin system, automatic needle threader & easy stitch selection. Just turn the stitch selector and wait for it to show in red. This workhorse has 18-built-in stitches, extra add-ons and adjustable settings that most beginners and experienced users find useful.
- Smooth and operation
- Really heavy-duty sewing unit
- Works with different fabrics
- Amazing stitch quality
- Not the best choice for newbies
- Not the prettiest sewing machine
SINGER Heavy Duty 4423 Sewing Machine
(Best All Metal Sewing Machine)
Are you new to the sewing industry? If yes, you probably do not know that 4423 by Singer dominates the market. I am talking about a heavy-duty mechanical sewing machine that will blow your mind away. It has a lot of features and add-ons to offer to every beginner, intermediate and experienced sewer.
You will get 23 built-in stitches that will assist you in completing all types of projects that come in mind. Also, another reason why this machine dominates the world of mechanical sewing machines is because of the speed. It has a speed of 1,1000 SPM. It has a super powerful motor that novice finds intimidating.
- Super easy to use
- Works with many fabrics
- It delivers professional results
- Automatic needle threader
- Amazing customer support
- Sturdy construction
- Not the best choice for novice
- Issues with denim & leather reported
- Not the prettiest sewing machine
Janome 2212 Sewing Machine
(Mechanical Sewing Machine with Speed Control)
Looking for a simple but efficient and functional unit, Janome 2212 is the ideal choice for you. It comes with 12 built-in stitches, excellent performance, and many add-ons. It is not perfect but it is pretty close to becoming perfect thanks to the user-friendly interface & simplicity. Beginners adore this workhorse.
Have I mentioned that it has a stitching speed of 860 SPM and is covered by a 25-year limited warranty? However, let’s review the most important pros and cons of this baby before you make a final purchase. Every sewing unit has its advantages & disadvantages, so let’s review the most important ones in 2212.
- Perfect for both newbies and pros
- Simple set-up and extremely easy to use
- Affordable, versatile and portable
- Small workspace
- Bobbin issues reported
- Difficult speed control
Brother XL-3750 Free-Arm Sewing Machine
(Best Mechanical Sewing Machine for Quilting)
Searching for a lightweight, convertible unit with additional quilting features and lots of stitches & stitch functions? If yes, XL-3750 free-arm sewing machine by Brother is ideal for you. It comes with 7 accessory presser feet, sewing notions, cloth carrying case, sewing notions, manual & integrated transport handle.
It also has a drop-in bobbin, 1-step auto-size buttonholer, auto needle threader, stitch length and width control. However, it is a 110-volt unit that is not recommended for use in states that do not support 120 V AC, no matter if a voltage adapter is in use. Let’s review the important pros and cons of this machine.
- Clear & detailed instructions
- Suitable for light and heavy fabrics
- Practical, efficient and lightweight
- Easy to use, portable and cheap
- Carrying handle included
- Plastic-made pedal
- Possible tension adjustment issues
- Mechanical sewing machine foot pedal cord is too short
- Too fast for newbies
- No drop feed lever
Janome HD1000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine
(Best Mechanical Sewing Machine 2018)
Have you ever heard of Janome HD1000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine? If you like Janome, you will love this unit. It is ideal for beginners & professionals thanks to advanced features including free accessories, 14 built-in sewing stitches with 4-step buttonhole, sturdy construction & an automatic needle threader.
You will get this machine with free add-ons including extra needles, seam ripper, various feet, softcover, bobbins, and so on. It also features a drop feed, free arm for sleeves & additional free-motion add-ons.
- Perfect for novice
- Many advanced features
- Extra free-motion add-ons
- Best sewing machine manual
- Automatic needle threader
- Sturdy construction
- Hard instructions
Janome 2206 Sewing Machine
(Mechanical Sewing Machine with Automatic Thread Cutter)
No matter if you are a returning sewist or just a beginner, you will find Janome 2206 absolutely amazing. It is a full-size, mechanical unit with six built-in stitches with a 4-step buttonhole & stitch pattern and width selection that is super easy to control. It also has a snap-on presser foot & a built-in thread cutter.
Other features include front-loading vertical oscillating hook bobbin system, 5-piece feed dog, free arm, drop feed, 2 retractable, vertical spool pins, extra-high presser foot lift, and a dust cover. However, just like any other sewing machine, 2206 has its pros and cons, so let’s check them out before you purchase.
- Sturdy, high-quality construction
- Ideally illuminated sewing workspace
- Clear instructions and super easy to use
- Lightweight, compact and efficient
- Affordable and ideal for beginners
- A plastic foot controller
- No automatic needle threader
- A limited number of stitches
Brother XR3774 Full-Featured Quilting Machine
(Best High-End Mechanical Sewing Machine)
If you want a high-end sewing & quilting unit, XR3774 is ideal for you. I am referring to a full-featured quilting machine that will blow you away. It is straightforward which makes it perfect for beginners but it is well-constructed and advanced as well which makes it great for intermediate users and pros too.
If you want to order this unit, just to boost your confidence I will reveal that you will get a versatile unit with 37 built-in sewing stitches and a large table for completing larger projects such as quilts. It also has a lot of presser feet, a sewing speed of 800 stitches per minute, bright workspace, and built-in threader.
- User manual
- Super versatile and cheap
- A lot of sewing feet included
- User-friendly & brightly lit
- It comes pre-oiled
- Small throat
- Needle threader issues reported
Janome Magnolia 7318 Sewing Machine
A specific device that I usually mention is the Janome Magnolia 7318 mechanical sewing unit. It comes with a decent number of stitches including a 4-step buttonhole and other impeccable features. It is easy to use which makes it perfect for a novice. However, it is not a good sewing unit for experienced sewers.
Still, it has everything you need to get started and complete a basic sewing project. It provides guidance manual & other accessories that you will find extremely useful on your way to becoming a professional.
- It operates well with various feet
- Stable, compact and visible bobbin
- Portable and adorable machine
- High transport costs
- Drop feed in the back
SINGER Heavy Duty 4432 Sewing Machine
A hardcore mechanical sewing unit that is worth your attention is 4432 by Singer. As you probably know, Singer has some of the best sewing machines on the market and this model is one of them. It is made for both beginners and advanced users. Experts adore this machine because it handles heavy-duty projects.
However, it is lightweight, compact and affordable. I can honestly say it is one of the greatest bargains in the market. You will get a sewing speed of 1,1000 stitches per minute and 32 stitches that will assist you in realizing every sewing project. It also has a powerful motor & provides super-easy sewing experience.
- Reliable and cheap
- Traditional design
- Customer support
- A heavy-duty unit
- Not the prettiest sewing unit
- Not the most portable machine
Brother XM2701 Sewing Machine
(Best Mechanical Sewing Machine for Beginners)
A Brother sewing machine that is perfect for beginners is XM2701 that offers a great sewing experience. It features 27 built-in stitches, six quick-changing feet, an automatic 1-step buttonhole. It also has a free arm, built-in needle threader and user-friendly interface which makes it ideal for enthusiastic beginners.
- Fast speed change
- Not recommended for use in states that do not support 120V AC
SINGER Simple 3232 Sewing Machine
It does not matter if you are a newbie or expert in sewing, you will find Singer Simple 3232 sewing unit exceptional. As the name of this machine suggests, it is a simple sewing machine with 32 built-in sewing stitches including a 1-step buttonhole and heavy-duty metal frame which makes it great for pros as well.
If you purchase this unit, you will have fun while making your crafts. Also, automatic features like needle threader make this unit stress-free and simple to use. It has high presser foot lifter, adjustable height & position, and an automatic reverse button. You can sew in reverse at a speed of 750 stitches per minute.
- Great for heavy-duty projects
- A powerful motor & high speed
- Perfect for pros and novice
- Some novice find it hard to use
- Warranted for US and Canadian use only
SINGER Heavy Duty 4411 Sewing Machine
Looking for a low-maintenance sewing machine that does not require professional skills to sew? If yes, how about you order Singer Heavy-Duty 4411 Sewing Machine today? It is super easy to use and comes with 11 built-in stitches including a 1-programmed 4-step buttonhole and reaches up to 1,100 SPM.
Other features you will get are foot control, knitting guide, screwdriver, 4 presser feet, control rope and delicate sided spread. It is absolutely amazing and delivers quiet work. If you want a lightweight, heavy-duty, super fast and portable sewing device, this is the unit for you. However, let’s review the downfalls.
- Heavy-duty unit
- Quiet operation
- Intended for basic projects
- No automatic needle threader
Brother ST371HD Strong and Tough Sewing Machine
(Modern Mechanical Sewing Machine)
The Brother ST371HD machine is both strong and extreme. It is extreme and proposed for high volumes of work, for instance, sewing denim, cowhide and completing other extreme and fun sewing adventures.
It offers top results & precision. Dependable, solid and adaptable, this Brother sewing machine will give you a straightforward and empowering sewing learning. It can sew different materials including denim, silk, and heavy denim. It is in like manner said to be the greatest unshakable sewing machine for canvas.
- A lot of plastic components
- No automatic needle threader
SINGER Tradition 2277 Sewing Machine
On the off chance that you are new to the specialty and you need to figure out how to sew, Tradition 2277 is the best sewing machine for you. It has 23 stitches, a fully-programmed 1-step buttonhole, auto-needle threader, flexible line length and width, extra-high presser foot lifter and lots of other features.
It is simply ideal for amateurs anxious to figure out how to sew quickly & remain spurred to adapt much more later on. Other than the highlights & adornments that I have just referenced, you will get this unit with different highlights and extras also including programmed needle tension and easy stitch selection.
- Stable and portable
- Automatic bobbin winding
- Ideal for novice
- Table not large enough
- No monogramming & quilt
SINGER Start 1304 Sewing machine
(Best Mechanical Sewing Machine for Home Use)
On the off chance that you are searching for a basic & easy to use sewing unit that is appropriate for everyone, Start 1304 is the ideal decision for you. It has the greatest embellishments and highlights to enable you to begin sewing without entanglements. It is the least difficult sewing unit for home use.
Sewers who travel regularly can think that its supportive since it is minimized, versatile & does not take a great deal of room. It has a 750 SPM, programmed bobbin winding framework and different add-ons.
- Easy to use
- Ideal for novice
- Jams frequently
- Limited speed control
Brother XM1010 Sewing Machine
Another incredible Brother sewing machine is the XM1010 versatile унит that is lightweight yet full-sized sewing machine expected for ordinary use. It accompanies 10 built-in stitches and 1 4-advance auto-size buttonhole. It is a sewing machine with automatic needle threader which makes it perfect for beginners.
What's more, a simple stitch selector that enables you to browse utility, stretch 7 embellishing lines and buttonhole. You will get this unit with a 25-year restricted guarantee and free help until the end of time.
- Automatic needle threader
- Customer support
- No thread tension control
- Only 10 built-in stitch patterns
What is a Mechanical Sewing Machine?
Mechanical sewing machines are straightforward, basic units that operate with knobs in order to adjust settings. A high-end mechanical machine usually has more buttonhole stitches & decorative stitches but in general, this is what a mechanical unit means. It delivers less precise stitches than computerized units.
Pros of Mechanical Sewing Machine
If you used a mechanical sewing machine in a sewing class or had one at home, it is natural that you like mechanical units more than computerized ones. They feel familiar to work with. And you do not have to learn new things constantly in order to keep track with your machine as users of computerized units do.
Many people would choose a mechanical sewing machine over a computerized one because it is easy or simple to use. If you are a beginner, your best chance at learning how to sew is with a mechanical unit in my opinion. Once you feel confident enough, you can make an upgrade and buy a computerized model.
As you would expect, mechanical units cost less than digital ones. You can buy a best-selling mechanical machine and not drain your bank account. Computerized units cost significantly more. However, choose what you can afford. Good computerized or mechanical sewing units can be found at a reasonable price.
Cons of Mechanical Sewing Machine
A limited number of stitches
If you prefer hundreds of stitches in your sewing machine, a mechanical unit is not a great choice for you because it comes with a limited number of stitches.
Fewer buttonhole options
If you like creating clothes, then a mechanical sewing unit is not suitable for you. Mechanical units have a limited choice of buttonholes, unlike computerized ones.
What is The Best Mechanical Sewing Machine?
A good mechanical sewing machine is supposed to be user-friendly and provide the ability to stitch any project you have in mind. It also should be able to handle a heavy flow of work and not cost a lot. Also, it is known that this industry is dominated by a few respected brands including Brother, Singer & Janome.
Meaning, a good mechanical sewing machine can be found by these brands. Also, there is another thing you need to keep in mind when buying a mechanical sewing unit in order to pick the best one for you. It is how a sewing machine is made. Does it contain metal or plastic parts? It is heavy or a lightweight unit?
This is a great way to compare the longevity and quality of mechanical machines. Throughout history, it is clear that sewing machines lasted longer. It is because they were made of metal.
Meaning, they were heavy-duty sewing machines, unlike today’s devices that break easily because most contain plastic parts.
How to determine if a mechanical machine has a quality, long-lasting construction? One way is to check if the bobbin hook is made of plastic. If it is, avoid that machine. Usually, cheaper sewing machines have a plastic bobbin hook while high-tech units have a metal one that lasts longer and does not break easily.
Another way to check is by noticing the weight of a unit. Most units under $150 contain a lot of plastic parts which makes them super light. This is great for beginners who want something portable, light and super easy to use but it is not that good for intermediate & advanced users who search for a sturdy unit.
How to Choose The Best Mechanical Sewing Machine?
Buying a mechanical sewing machine does not have to be a struggle anymore. Now, you have me and my mechanical sewing machine reviews by your side. I will list the few key features you need to keep in mind when shopping for mechanical sewing machine online and any other sewing machine, in general.
The sewing speed of your machine matters for 2 reasons. First, the faster the unit, the quicker you will get to finish your projects and search for new ones. Second, sewing speed matters for beginners. If you are a novice, working at higher speeds can mess up your projects and lower the quality of your sewing.
Therefore, working at speeds below 1,000 stitches per minute works perfectly for beginners. However, in case you are a pro, you need to choose a faster sewing machine in order to get things done better and faster. I personally suggest that you buy a sewing unit with a sewing speed of 1,400 stitches per minute.
Number of Stitches
The second important feature is the number of built-in stitches. Usually, units with more stitches have more decorative stitch patterns, making them perfect for tasks that require a polished, beautiful finish. Meaning, the more built-in stitches your sewing machine has, the better, but also the higher the price.
If you are a beginner who wants to complete basic projects at start, choose a machine with basic stitch patterns instead of spending a bunch of money on high-end sewing machines with features that you will not be using any time soon. However, if you are an advanced user, choose a model with many stitches.
Next, you need to pay attention to the construction of your machine, especially if you plan to work with denim, leather and other stubborn fabrics. If you want to complete heavy-duty projects, you will need a heavy-duty model. And what makes a sewing machine heavy duty is metal frame and a powerful motor.
Most sewing units come with handy features. However, some have more than others. Make sure that it has basic handy features such as LED-lit area, automatic needle threader, reverse stitching, auto bobbin winding, accessories tray, free arm for sleeves & legs and a top drop-in bobbin with a transparent cover.
Make sure that your sewing machine comes with all the necessary accessories to help you get started. Otherwise, you will have to purchase them separately which means you will have to spend extra money. Accessories include extra bobbins, seam and button reapers, needles, feet and screwdrivers and so on.
With computerized units, it is important to get a decent warranty cover, in case something goes wrong. But if you want to buy a mechanical machine make sure that it is covered by a 25-year limited warranty.
Mechanical Sewing Machines and Their Uses
Mechanical sewing units represent a great solution for some users, especially newbies and people who switch from a classic item to something more advanced. Apparently, they find computerized units hard to use. However, there is nothing wrong with that because mechanical sewing units last longer anyway.
Also, you can save a lot of money on replacement parts, as the parts of mechanical units are cheap and easy to find. The annoying thing about digitized sewing machines is that there are electronic parts that go inside and only a professional can fix them if broken which is not the case with mechanical machines.
Mechanical sewing machine repair can be done by an experienced sewer with basic repair knowledge.
Mechanical Sewing Machine vs Computerized
The biggest difference between a mechanical sewing machine uses & computerized machines is in the user interface. Currently, a lot of companies say mechanical machines as having twist knows or levers to make any setting. Also, mechanical units have fewer stitches which stand as another big disadvantage.
Computerized and electronic units, on the other hand, have multiple stitch patterns, push buttons for easy selection, LCD screen and offer precise stitching. Other pros of purchasing a computerized sewing unit include versatility, precise stitching, handling thicker fabrics and specialized & automated features.
Mechanical Sewing Machine vs Electronic Sewing Machine
Electronic sewing units are perceived as a ‘hybrid’ between computerized & manual sewing machines.
They provide a wide variety of decorative and utility stitches, multiple styles of buttonholes & alphabet, however, they do not allow to do embroidery. They also have an LCD screen for exact stitch adjustment.
Mechanical sewing machines provide fewer stitch designs but greater stability, durability & decent price, unlike electronic sewing machines which can be very expensive for beginners, especially advanced ones.
In conclusion, this type of machine is not as limited as compared to computerized or electronic devices. However, it comes with fewer stitches than modern machines. Still, most mechanical machines provide all the necessary features you need to complete different projects. Also, they are affordable and simple.
I would recommend Brother XM2701 Sewing Machine and SINGER Heavy Duty 4411 Sewing Machine for beginners because they are cheap and easy to use. However, when it comes to advanced users, they can make the most out of their projects with a unit like Janome HD3000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine.
After going through my mechanical sewing machine reviews, I hope that you will be in a better position to choose the best mechanical sewing machine that meets your needs and requirements. Do not forget to share this article with your loved ones. Also, do not hesitate to share your opinion and ask questions.